Should Germany have its own nuclear weapons?

Poll results

Should Germany have its own nuclear weapons?
Support
Reject
Don't know
36%
59%
4%
PolitPro Community – 4001 respondents – 26.10.2023-02.11.2023

Poll information

Should Germany have its own nuclear weapons? 36% voted in favor of Germany possessing its own nuclear weapons, 59% against.

4% chose the answer "Don't know". The survey was conducted among 4001 users of the PolitPro app during 26.10.2023-02.11.2023. The results are not representative, but may give a rough idea of the political mood around the issue.

Pros - What's in favor?

  1. Security and Defense: Possession of its own nuclear weapons would give Germany an independent nuclear deterrent capability and serve as a safeguard against potential threats. In an uncertain international security situation, possession of its own nuclear weapons could serve as a guarantee for the defense of Germany's national interests and security.
  2. Influence and Responsibility: As one of Europe's leading economic and political powers, possession of its own nuclear weapons could give Germany greater influence in international affairs. Nuclear weapons are viewed by some countries as an instrument of power, and possession of its own nuclear weapons could strengthen Germany's position in negotiations and international relations. It would also let Germany assume greater responsibility for nuclear disarmament and nonproliferation.
  3. Deterrence potential: Possessing its own nuclear weapons could have a deterrent effect on potential aggressors and contribute to stability in the international order. The credibility of a nuclear deterrent could deter potential aggressors from attacking Germany or threatening its interests.

Cons - What's against it?

  1. International obligations and disarmament: Germany has already committed itself to nuclear disarmament and nonproliferation under the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. Possessing its own nuclear weapons would contradict these commitments and weaken the global effort to achieve a nuclear-weapon-free world. It would be a step backward in international efforts to reduce and control nuclear weapons.
  2. Escalation Risk and Security Concerns: Possession of our own nuclear weapons could lead to escalation in international conflicts and increase the likelihood of nuclear war. Nuclear weapons are extremely destructive and their use would pose an enormous threat to humanity. Not possessing our own nuclear weapons contributes to nuclear security and stability.
  3. Costs and Resources: Possessing our own nuclear weapons would come at a significant cost. Nuclear weapons programs require extensive infrastructure, maintenance, modernization, and security measures. These resources could be better spent on other areas, such as education, health, or renewable energy development, that directly promote the well-being of the population.